Is AutoCrit or ProWritingAid better?

In our editorial assessment ProWritingAid scores 4.4/5 versus AutoCrit's 4.0/5. ProWritingAid stands out for deep, fiction-friendly revision reports, while AutoCrit is worth a look for fiction-specific, data-driven edits. The right choice depends on your workflow — see the breakdown above.

Do AutoCrit or ProWritingAid have a free version?

Both AutoCrit and ProWritingAid offer a free tier. You can start there before committing to a paid plan.

AutoCrit vs ProWritingAid

A side-by-side comparison of AutoCrit and ProWritingAid for writers — pricing, features and where each one earns its place.

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. It never affects our rankings.

	AutoCrit	ProWritingAid
Tagline	Genre-aware AI editing benchmarked against published fiction.	All-in-one grammar, style and manuscript editor with AI rewrites.
Editorial rating	★★★★☆4.0editorial	★★★★☆4.4editorial
Pricing	Free; Pro from US$30/mo	Free; Premium US$30/mo (lifetime from US$399)
Free tier	Yes	Yes
Good for	Fiction	Fiction, Copywriting, Academic
Categories	Editing	Editing, Grammar
Models	Proprietary + AI	Proprietary + AI
Platforms	web	web, desktop, browser-ext, word, docs

AutoCrit

Pros

Fiction-specific, data-driven edits
Genre benchmarking is genuinely unique
Catches overused words and phrases

Cons

Editing only — no drafting
Reports can overwhelm beginners
Best features are paid

Visit AutoCrit ↗

ProWritingAid

Pros

Deep, fiction-friendly revision reports
Lifetime pricing option exists
Integrates into most writing apps

Cons

Feature overload for beginners
Real-time checks can lag on long docs
Best reports are behind Premium

Visit ProWritingAid ↗

Our verdict

ProWritingAid edges ahead on our editorial score (4.4 vs 4.0), largely for deep, fiction-friendly revision reports. That said, AutoCrit is the better pick if fiction-specific, data-driven edits matters more to you.

Frequently asked questions

Is AutoCrit or ProWritingAid better?: In our editorial assessment ProWritingAid scores 4.4/5 versus AutoCrit's 4.0/5. ProWritingAid stands out for deep, fiction-friendly revision reports, while AutoCrit is worth a look for fiction-specific, data-driven edits. The right choice depends on your workflow — see the breakdown above.
Do AutoCrit or ProWritingAid have a free version?: Both AutoCrit and ProWritingAid offer a free tier. You can start there before committing to a paid plan.

Read the full reviews: AutoCrit · ProWritingAid · all comparisons